If you are planning to build a swimming pool in your backyard, getting multiple quotes from pool builders is a smart place to start. Comparing different pool companies can help you understand your options, explore different designs, and determine what is included in your project.
But there is a common problem homeowners run into when comparing pool quotes: not every quote is actually for the same pool.
One pool builder may include equipment, features, decking, or site work that another builder has left out. One proposal may use different materials or equipment specifications. Another may include certain upgrades as part of the package while treating them as additional options elsewhere.
When that happens, simply comparing the final price doesn’t tell you very much.
If you want to make an informed decision when comparing pool builders, you need to make sure you are comparing apples to apples.
What Does “Apples to Apples” Mean When Comparing Pool Quotes?
When homeowners talk about comparing pool quotes, they often start with the bottom line.
That makes sense. A swimming pool is a major home improvement project, and the overall investment matters.
However, the number at the bottom of a proposal only makes sense when you understand what is included above it.
An apples-to-apples comparison means looking at the same basic pool design, construction scope, materials, equipment, features, finishes, site work, and other project details from each pool builder.
If one contractor is quoting a basic pool and another is quoting a more customized pool with additional features, those two proposals aren’t really competing on equal terms.
Before comparing the numbers, compare the scope of the project.
Start With the Same Pool Design
The first step in comparing pool construction quotes is making sure each pool company is working from the same general design.
The pool’s shape, size, depth, steps, benches, tanning ledges, spas, water features, and other design elements can all affect the construction process.
A custom pool builder may also approach the layout differently based on the property and the homeowner’s goals.
At Backyard Innovations we specialize in custom pool design, with pool designs created in-house to fit the homeowner’s space and preferences.
That means homeowners should be careful when comparing a highly customized design with a generic pool package from another contractor.
If you want a true comparison, ask each pool builder to quote the same basic design and features.
Look at What Each Pool Quote Includes
Once the designs are comparable, look closely at the scope of work.
This is where many differences between pool quotes begin to appear.
Instead of simply asking how much the pool will cost, ask each contractor to explain exactly what is included in the proposed project.
Look at the construction of the pool itself, the plumbing and electrical work, pool equipment, interior finish, tile, coping, decking, lighting, automation, heating, water features, cleanup, permitting, and other applicable project requirements.
The exact scope will depend on your property and the pool you are building, but every item should be clearly understood before you compare proposals.
A quote that appears less expensive on the surface may simply include less work.
Compare Pool Equipment Carefully
Pool equipment is another area where two seemingly similar quotes can be very different.
Ask each pool builder what equipment they are proposing and whether the specifications are comparable.
The pump, filter, sanitation system, heater, automation, lighting, and other equipment can all affect how your pool operates and how it will be maintained over time.
This is particularly important if you are interested in a more automated pool system.
Backyard Innovations provides pool equipment installation, replacement, maintenance, and upgrades in addition to new pool construction, so equipment is an important part of the company’s broader pool services.
When comparing quotes, don’t just look for the words “pool equipment included.” Find out what equipment is actually being proposed.
Don’t Overlook Pool Finishes and Materials
The visible materials used in a swimming pool can have a significant impact on the finished appearance.
When comparing pool construction quotes, look at the interior finish, waterline tile, coping, decking, decorative materials, and finishes associated with water features.
Two proposals might both say that they include tile or a premium finish, but the actual products and specifications could be different.
This is why it helps to ask the pool builder to identify the materials being included in the proposal.
You don’t necessarily need to become an expert in every pool product available. You simply want enough information to determine whether the proposals are actually comparable.
Make Sure You Understand the Site Work
Your property can have a major influence on the pool-building process.
Access to the backyard, existing landscaping, structures, drainage, soil conditions, elevation changes, utility locations, and other property-specific considerations can all affect construction.
A pool quote based on one property’s conditions may not be directly comparable to a quote based on another set of assumptions.
When interviewing pool builders, ask what they have considered about your specific property and whether any site conditions could affect the scope of work.
The more that can be discussed before construction begins, the fewer surprises there may be later.
Ask What Is Not Included
One of the most useful questions you can ask a pool builder is also one of the simplest:
“What is not included in this quote?”
Homeowners naturally focus on what they are getting. But exclusions can be just as important.
A proposal might not include certain landscaping, fencing, additional electrical work, drainage modifications, upgrades, outdoor living features, or other work depending on the project.
That doesn’t necessarily mean the quote is incomplete. It simply means you need to know what falls inside and outside the scope of the proposal.
Once you understand the exclusions, you can compare the proposals much more accurately.
Compare Outdoor Living Features Too
For many homeowners, building a swimming pool is only part of a larger backyard transformation.
You may also be considering an outdoor kitchen, patio area, additional decking, landscaping, lighting, fire features, or other outdoor living improvements.
If those features are part of your plans, make sure you understand whether they are included in the pool quote or handled separately.
At Backyard Innovations we offer outdoor living solutions in addition to custom pool construction, including outdoor kitchens and other backyard improvements.
Looking at the entire project rather than only the swimming pool can make your comparison much more useful.
Compare Pool Builders, Not Just Pool Prices
The company you hire matters just as much as the design you choose.
Before selecting a pool contractor, research their experience, reputation, licensing, insurance, portfolio, communication, and approach to construction.
Backyard Innovations is a family-owned and operated full-service pool contractor serving Northeast Florida, with more than 30 years of pool-building experience. The company also states that its owner oversees each pool building or renovation process.
When comparing pool builders, ask who will oversee your project and who you will communicate with throughout construction.
A clear process and reliable communication can make a substantial difference during a construction project.
Verify Your Pool Contractor’s License
Licensing is another important part of researching a pool builder.
Florida homeowners can use the state’s Department of Business and Professional Regulation to verify contractor licensing information. The DBPR provides an online license verification system that allows consumers to search for licensed professionals and businesses.
You can use the official Florida DBPR license verification system as part of your research when comparing pool contractors.
Florida DBPR License Verification
Taking a few minutes to verify licensing can give you another useful piece of information when evaluating a pool company.
Look at Completed Pool Projects
A pool builder’s portfolio can tell you a lot about the type of work they perform.
Look at completed projects and pay attention to the details rather than simply looking at the overall pool shape.
Consider how the pool integrates with the backyard, how the decking transitions into the surrounding space, how water features are incorporated, and how the finishes work together.
If you have a particular style in mind, ask whether the builder has completed projects with similar design elements.
Read Pool Builder Reviews With the Bigger Picture in Mind
Online reviews can also be helpful when researching pool companies.
Rather than focusing on one review, look for recurring themes.
Do customers consistently mention communication? Do they discuss the quality of construction? Do they describe how the company handled questions or issues during the project?
Reviews shouldn’t be the only factor in your decision, but they can provide additional insight into what homeowners experienced while working with a particular contractor.
Compare the Contract, Not Just the Estimate
The estimate is only one part of the pool-building process.
Before signing a contract, make sure you understand the project’s scope, payment structure, timeline, warranty information, change-order process, selections, allowances, and responsibilities.
If something is unclear, ask the pool builder to explain it before signing.
A detailed conversation at the beginning of a project can help establish expectations for everyone involved.
Why the Lowest Pool Quote May Not Be the Same Pool
It is easy to look at several pool estimates and immediately focus on the lowest number.
But if the proposals have different scopes, materials, equipment, or features, the lowest quote may simply represent a different project.
This is why comparing pool quotes should be about more than finding the lowest initial price.
The better question is:
“What exactly am I getting for this quote?”
Once you understand the answer, you can compare the proposals based on the actual projects being offered.
Create a Side-by-Side Pool Quote Comparison
A simple way to compare pool builders is to put their proposals next to each other and review the same categories.
Start with the pool design. Then compare construction, equipment, finishes, decking, features, site work, outdoor living components, warranties, timelines, and exclusions.
If one contractor has included something that another hasn’t, ask the second contractor whether it can be added to the proposal.
Likewise, if one proposal includes a different material or equipment package, ask the builders to explain the difference.
The goal isn’t necessarily to make every proposal identical.
The goal is to understand why the proposals are different.
Questions to Ask Before Choosing a Pool Builder
Before you make your decision, have a conversation with each pool company about the details of your project.
Ask what is included, what is excluded, what equipment is being proposed, what materials are included, who will oversee the project, and how changes are handled during construction.
Ask about the construction process and what you should expect from the beginning of the project through completion.
Most importantly, don’t be afraid to ask questions about anything you don’t understand.
A professional pool builder should be willing to walk you through the proposal and explain what you are actually purchasing.
Comparing Pool Quotes Doesn’t Have to Be Complicated
Getting multiple pool quotes is a great way to research your options, but the comparison only works when you understand what each pool builder is actually offering.
Start with the same pool design. Compare the construction scope. Look at equipment and materials. Understand the site work. Review what’s included and what’s excluded. Research the contractor. Verify licensing. Read reviews. Then carefully review the contract before moving forward.
When you take the time to compare the entire project rather than simply comparing the final number, you can make a much more informed decision about your new swimming pool.
Build Your Custom Pool With Backyard Innovations
At Backyard Innovations we are a family-owned and operated pool contractor serving Northeast Florida. We specialize in custom pool construction and also provide pool renovations, maintenance, equipment services, and outdoor living solutions.
If you’re comparing pool builders in Northeast Florida and want to discuss your backyard, design ideas, or pool-building project, contact Backyard Innovations to learn more about the process and request an estimate.
Backyard Innovations Pools
Phone: (904) 868-2608
Contact Backyard Innovations Pools
